Examine the table on the next page, where countries performances at the atlanta olympics are tabulated. Braglia 2000 proposed a multiattribute approach based on analytic hierarchical process ahp and named his approach multiattribute failure mode analysis mafma. This means that an overall value of a given alternative is calculated as the total sum of the performance score value of each criterion attribute multiplied with the. Braglia 7 proposed a multi attribute failure mode analysis mafma by integrating traditional fmea and economic considerations based on the analytic hierarchy process ahp technique for evaluating the criticality of a failure cause with different weights. For large and complex systems, since multiple failures of components exist, assessing multiple failure modes with all possible combinations is. Differences across products, consumers, and shopping stages aron m. In reliability theory, the most important problem is to determine the. The first, salient beliefs, is a reference to the beliefs a person might gain during the evaluation of a product or service. Stamatis has updated his comprehensive reference book on failure mode and effect analysis fmea this is one of the most comprehensive guides to fmea and is excellent for professionals with any level of understanding. To enhance the effectiveness of fmea, a great many multi criteria decision making mcdm methods have been applied for properly evaluating the risk of failure modes over the past two decades. According to vaughan 7, the lack of consideration of economic aspects into one of the weaknesses of fmea. The general process for systematically approaching these types of problems is called multi attribute decision analysis mada. Failure mode and effects analysis fmea originated from the national aeronautics and space administration nasa. The aim of this paper is to develop a new tool for reliability and failure mode analysis by integrating the conventional aspects of the popular failure mode and criticality analysis fmeca procedure with economic considerations.
Failure mode and effects analysis is designed to identify, prioritize and limit these failure modes. Failure mode effects analysis advanced asq section 501. When it is used for a criticality analysis, it is also referred to as failure mode. So that research results obtained from waste is often the case critical waste in the production process is the dosing powder bulk oil mix. Moderate 6 may detect the existence of a failure mode. Salah satu metode yang dapat digunakan dalam manajemen risiko adalah multiattribute failure mode analysis mafma. These procedures ensure that nothing will be missed and that the correct diagnosis is found. To enhance the effectiveness of fmea, a great many multicriteria decision making mcdm methods have been applied for properly evaluating the risk of failure modes over the past two decades. Process has a good chance to automatically detect failure. Citeseerx document details isaac councill, lee giles, pradeep teregowda. Conflicting criteria are typical in evaluating options. A weight restricted dea model for fmea risk prioritization. The technique is specifically intended to overcome some of the limitations concerning the use of the conventional us mil.
Multifactor failure mode critically analysis using topsis. New failure mode and effect analysis approach considering. Failure mode and effect analysis in a linguistic context. Using the lettersofthe alphabet in order,this is howdictionaries or lexicons order words hence,lexicographic. To resolve the shortcomings of the conventional rpn method, a great number of studies have been conducted on the improvement of fmea and a variety of alternative approaches have been proposed. In this model, the scores against each failure mode are expressed in grey number instead of crisp values to evaluate the criticalities of the failure modes.
Item check point 1 check body for damages hits, corrosion, overheat. Compressor teardown compressor teardown procedure when tearing down a compressor to determine failure mode, it is important to follow the correct procedure. Fuzzy failure mode and effect analysis application to. Xyz often suffers stopline in its production process of producing tin plate type coil in electrolytic tinning line etl machine which is used nonstop. This version presented is a very rudimentary version of the ffbd.
To aid the analyst to formulate an efficient and effective priority ranking of the possible causes of failure, the analytic hierarchy process technique is. Fuzzy topsis approach for failure mode, effects and. Within healthcare, the goal is to avoid adverse events that could potentially cause harm to patients, families, employees or others in the patient care setting. This paper describes the extending model of multi mode failure models by using the weibull and gamma distribution models presented in a conference 1,2.
Multimode failure models for attribute test data in. It is widely used in manufacturing industries in different stages of the product life cycle and is now increasingly finding use in the service industry. Metode multi attribute failure mode analysis mafma merupakan salah satu metode yang digunakan untuk mengeliminasi kegagalan. Practical attribute and variable measurement systems analysis. Quality, variety, and product guarantees are the top three attributes in the hypothetical analysis shown in table 1. Fmea failure mode and effects analysis is a proactive tool, technique and quality method that enables the identification and prevention of process or product errors before they occur. Multi attribute failure mode analysis mafma is a method of integrating the failure mode and effect analysis fmea conventional by considering economic aspects 6. Failure mode and effect, 2004 a functional flow block diagramffbd is a multitier, timesequenced, stepbystep flow diagram of a systems functional flow. Generalized multiattribute failure mode analysis sciencedirect. A numerical illustration is provided towards the end of the paper. Multicriteria fmeca based decisionmaking for aluminium. For each component, the failure modes and their resulting effects on the rest of the system are recorded in a specific fmea. Multiattribute decision making manydecisions are based on other attributes than price.
Analysis of potential failure modes in an assembly line by. Thus, managers can rank and assess the risk of potential failure modes per the rpn data, initiating modification protocols for highrisk parts. Dalam mafma ditambahkan suatu faktor yakni faktor biaya expected cost selain severity, occurence dan detectability. Practical attribute and variable measurement systems. Dengan kata lain multi attribute failure mode analysis ma fma.
This paper describes the extending model of multimode failure models by using the weibull and gamma distribution models presented in a conference 1,2. Companies, such as walmart, can use the results from a multiattribute analysis to help improve their image. Hence it is pertinent to find the optimal release time during testing phase. Analysis, root cause analysis, and then make comparisons between the failure mode failure mode and effect analysis fmea and failure mode multi attribute analysis mafma.
A risk assessment approach for failure mode and effects. Fmea is a technique of analysis by a team or an expert to identify the. The importance of each attribute carries the most impact compared to the other variables used in the fishbein formula. Traditionally, a risk priority number is applied to capture the ranking order of failure modes in.
This paper presents a multifactor decisionmaking approach based on greycomplex proportional assessment coprasg method in a view to overcome the limitations of failure mode effect and criticality analysis fmeca. Braglia 2000 proposed a multi attribute approach based on analytic hierarchical process ahp and named his approach multi attribute failure mode analysis mafma. Multi attribute failure mode analysis m afma adalah metode yang dikembangkan dari failure mode and effect analysis f mea. Based on the results of mafma, then found the cause of the most critical due to cause c, the defects are sourced from the supplier on the part gear reducer. A multiattribute model can be used to measure a consumers overall attitude. Metode mafma merupakan pengembangan metode failure mode and effect analysis fmea dengan menambahkan faktor ekonomi atau biaya ke. Failure mode and effects analysis fmea is a very effective and useful engineering technique used for accident prevention and risk analysis, and it is applied to identify and eliminate known or potential failures to enhance the reliability and safety of a complex system 1,2. Traditionally, a risk priority number is applied to capture the ranking order of failure modes in failure. The aim of this paper is to develop a new tool for reliability and failure mode analysis by integrating the conventional aspects of the popular failure mode and criticality analysis fmeca. Comfor t, perf ormance, reliability,s iz e, safety,s tyle, ima ge, equipment. High 4 have a good chance of detecting failure mode. Failure mode and effect analysis using multicriteria.
One of those is multi attribute failure mode analysis mafma, which can be used to eliminate or minimize the failure probability based on its causal factor. Different than the models in the previous papers which are for variable test data, in this paper we will describe the use of attribute test data for our model. Levin department of psychology and department of marketing university of iowa irwin. They are machine factor, human, and material elements. Choosing a car, forinstance, although you might be looking in a particular price band. Dalam metode ini dapat diidentifikasi penyebabpenyebab terjadinya kegagalan, dan akan ditentukan penyebab kegagalan yang potensial. The first, salient beliefs, is a reference to the beliefs a person might gain during the. Analysis, root cause analysis, and then make comparisons between the failure mode failure mode and effect analysis fmea and failure mode multiattribute analysis mafma. The technique was first used in the aerospace industry to find problems with an aircraft before it ever left the ground.
Failure mode analysis azure architecture center microsoft. As a powerful preaccident risk evaluation method, the traditional failure mode and effect analysis fmea is extensively used to identify and eliminate the potential failure modes of products or processes, and presents several limitations simultaneously. Setelah diidentifikasi penyebab tersebut, kemudian menghitung. It is primarily a proactive technique in risk control that identifies critical risk events to avoid potential failure modes. Failure mode analysis fma is a process for building resiliency into a system, by identifying possible failure points in the system. Failure mode and effects analysis is an effective and powerful risk evaluation technique in the field of risk management, and it has been extensively used in various industries for identifying and decreasing known and potential failure modes in systems, processes, products, and services. The simple multi attribute rating technique smart the smart technique is based on a linear additive model. But testing cannot be done indefinitely due to many reasons ranging from marketing considerations to increase in cost. Multi attribute analysis an effective visualization. The mada process, in its simplest form consists of four stages.
Failure modes and effects analysis fmea reliability. Nov 07, 2008 failure mode and effects analysis fmea is a logical, proactive technique that is used to identify and eliminate potential causes of failures. Risk management and process failure mode and effects analysis. Dec 01, 2000 fmeca theory and the criticality assessment problem mafma. The author tries to find solutions to these problems by using multi attribute failure mode analysis mafma. The purpose of this research is identifying cause of stopline and determining the most potential cause of stopline using multi attribute failure mode analysis mafma.
None 10 can not detect the existence of a failure mode. Multiplecriteria decisionmaking mcdm or multiplecriteria decision analysis mcda is a subdiscipline of operations research that explicitly evaluates multiple conflicting criteria in decision making both in daily life and in settings such as business, government and medicine. Reprint pdf 284kb identification the potential causes of stopline in electrolytic tinning line using multi attribute failure mode analysis. The fma should be part of the architecture and design phases, so that you can build failure recovery into the system from the beginning. One of those is multi attribute failure mode analysis mafma, which can be used to eliminate or minimize the failure probability based on its causal factor, so we can prevent the same failure in the future. In a software development life cycle the testing phase is given a lot of importance. Failure mode and effect analysis fmea is a proactive reliability management technique extensively utilized in a variety of fields. There are 17 elements that found in it, according to the result of analysis in using the concept of approachment lean, six sigma, multi attribute failure mode analysis and fuzzy ahp is useful to identify the element m that it has over size. The most influential multiattribute modelthe fishbein modelalso uses three components of attitude. Failure mode and effects analysis considering consensus and. There are 17 elements that found in it, according to the result of analysis in using the concept of approachment lean, six sigma, multi attribute failure mode analysis and fuzzy ahp is useful. Failure mode and effects analysis fmea is a logical, proactive technique that is used to identify and eliminate potential causes of failures. Firms routinely face the challenging decision of when to stop testing and release. Fmeca theory and the criticality assessment problem mafma.
Annisa department of industrial engineering, university of sultan ageng tirtayasa, cilegon, indonesia. Multicriteria fmeca based decisionmaking for aluminium wire. The failure mode and effect analysis fmea is an engineering technique used to define, identify and eliminate known andor potential failures, problems, errors and so on from the system, design, process andor service before they reached the customer 2. Risk management and process failure mode and effects. Conventionally, the most popular method of evaluating critical failure risk in fmea is the rpn, which is the mathematical product of 3 parametersi. Paper open access the proposed improvements to minimize. In this approach the risk factors occurrence, severity, detectability and expected cost are considered as decision attributes. Multiple failures mode risk priority number weight risk priority number fmea abstract traditionally, failure mode and effects analysis fmea only considers the impact of single failure on the system. Metode ini merupakan pengembangan dari metode failure mode and effect analysis fmea. Failure mode and effects analysis considering consensus. Chapter 2 fmea using uncertainty theories and mcdm methods.
848 770 1498 1439 594 1325 106 1351 589 1581 1356 456 111 694 1572 1393 192 893 342 711 309 1032 946 540 254 1148 450 897 1580 1179 39 1400 282 65 780 938 97 986 1168